flag
backBack
How to Tamper With a Cricket Ball with a Sandpaper 101: Is it Actually Possible that the Bowlers Did Not Know?

Pat Cummins’ passionate 78-minute press conference refuting Usman Khawaja’s “we all knew” claim, comments from 12th man Chadd Sayers, and the testimony of the man himself, Cameron Bancroft, confirmed what we had all suspected: more than three people knew.

In his 4500-word article, Bancroft does concede that

“…there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used.”

Since there is a hint of doubt remaining, we want to learn what happens to a cricket ball when sandpaper is applied at each stage.

The Question

In 2018 in South Africa, was there any chance that the Australian pace attack did not know there was sandpaper being applied to the cricket ball?

I do not know this answer, for I have never tampered with the ball myself. So I decided to do an experiment. I tried to learn how to ball tamper with sandpaper from first principles via the scientific method.

The Prep

For this experiment, I bought a

Red cricket ball and sandpaper

The Hypothesis

I wanted to give the bowlers the benefit of the doubt and not start with any of my own internal biases. The two main possibilities were as follows:

  • H_0: Sandpaper marks stay distinguishable from the natural wear & tear at each stage
  • H_1: There is a stage after which sandpaper marks can no longer be reliably be told apart from the natural wear of the ball Here’s how both sides look at the start

The Experiment

Now to the crux of the matter, the actual experiment. We conducted this experiment in 3 stages:

  • Stage 1: Sandpaper was used on the new ball to see how sandpaper marks look on a cricket ball. This was used to compare the state of the ball at the very end to see if we can make out sandpaper tears versus natural wear and tear.
  • Stage 2: I then used a bat to knock the ball 240 times (so we can take the condition of the ball closer to the 40-over mark). Sandpaper was applied after this stage.
  • Stage 3: Finally, I went outside on a carpeted cricket pitch to try to get more natural wear and tear on the ball. I bowled 60 deliveries as follows:
    • Balls 1-12: No artificial substances used between deliveries. Ball shined and sandpaper used after Ball #12.
    • Balls 13-30: No artificial substances used between deliveries. Ball shined and sandpaper used after Ball #30.
    • Balls 31-48: Between each delivery, ball was shined and sandpaper was used on the rough side. Images were taken at Ball #36, #42, and #48.
    • Balls 49-60: Between each delivery, ball was shined, but sandpaper was no longer used.

Control Group

  • We kept the ‘Supreme’ side as the control variable where we would shine the ball (and not use any sandpaper).
  • We will only used Sandpaper in the logo side of the ball.

Methodology

For the first two stages and beginning of the third stage, we applied sandpaper 20 times (10 times in 2 different locations) on the ball, swiping from left to the right.

In the later stages of Stage 3 (where we sanded the rough side of the ball between every delivery), we applied sandpaper 4-5 times per use.

For shining the ball, I mainly used saliva with handkerchief followed by rubbing the ball on trouser (sweat was also an option, but was not used for this version of the experiment).

How Did the Original Ball Look Like?

For comparison, here is state of the original ball: The ‘Supreme’ hand stitched versus the logo side (this will be the sandpapered side).

Results and Observations

Stage 1: 11/20, 11:44 PM (New Ball)

After the initial round of sandpapering, this is how the ball looked like.

*Note: We are not testing how reverse swing works so I applied sandpaper on a new ball to see how the marks look even though this would not have happened in real life.

Stage 2: 11/21, 9:54-10:14 AM (Knocking)

Observations

Time Balls Knocked Observations
9:54-9:59 AM #1-60 Initially, I knocked the ball without stopping (so the bat may have hit both sides). After about Ball 5, I switched to catching the ball and dropping it again so only the rough side is knocked on.
10:01-10:04 AM #61-120
10:05-10:09 AM #121-180 I dropped balls #168 and 174 which hit the wooden floor. One of these instances caused a scratch on the shiny side of the ball.
10:11-10:14 AM #181-240 Ball #207 was dropped on the floor as well.

Here is the shiny side with the scratch.

After Stage 2 was complete, I applied sandpaper on the logo side 20 times again. This is how it looked.

Stage 3: 11/21, 10:50 AM-01:20 PM (Natural Conditions)

I wanted to take this up a notch and went outside and try to find different surfaces to get natural wear and tear of the ball.

  • 10:50-10:57 AM
    • Baseball cage (bounced 4 balls here, but it had inconsistent bounce)
    • Soccer Field (bounced 6 balls here, inconsistent bounce here as well)
    • Concrete parking lot (bounced a couple of times here)

I did not like any of these options so decided to drive to one of the local cricket ground.

  • 11:20-11:35 AM:
    • Carpeted cricket pitch (bowled 4 balls initially here, 3 from one end and 1 from the other, but the ball was getting lost in the autumn leaves on the hill)
    • Pure grass (2 balls, inconsistent bounce)
    • Baseball Bullpen with wooden plate chain link (3 balls, No bounce, hit the chain link once which might have caused a mark)

The Actual Experiment

Now that we had used the ball indoors and in different places, it was time to bowl my medium pace dibbly dobblies.

I ended up bowling 60 balls on this pitch and used sandpaper at different points.

Ball Check #1

  • 11:36 AM: Back to the cricket carpet
  • 11:52 AM: Ball Check #1 – 12 Deliveries Done, did not use artificial substances, between deliveries

After these 12 balls, I used sandpaper 20 times on the logo side of the ball and used saliva to shine the ‘Supreme’ side of the ball

Observation: Natural wear and tear had begin to occur on both sides of the ball at this stage.

Ball Check #2

  • Ball Check #2 12:01-12:25 PM: Bowled 18 more deliveries, did not use any artificial substances between deliveries.

Observation: At this stage, I could NOT distinguish if sandpaper had been previously used. I could see natural markings on both sides of the ball and any previous hints of sandpaper use was not evident.

Now that we had bowled 30 deliveries total, it was time to apply sandpaper again.

Ball Checks #3-5

From balls 31-48, I now used artificial substances between EVERY delivery.

After I would bowl, I would go pick up the ball. On the walk back, I would use saliva/handkerchief to shine the ‘Supreme’ side of the ball and rubbed the ball on my trousers. In addition, I used sandpaper 4-5 times between each delivery on the logo side.

  • 12:36 PM: Ball Check #3 after bowling 6 deliveries

Observation: Within 6 deliveries of sandpapering the logo side (to mimic the situation where each ball is going to the keeper > then to a fielder who shines the ball/sandpapers the rough side before throwing it back to the bowler), the logo completely disappeared. It left white marks, and you could definitely make out that an external substance was being used.

  • ~12:42 PM: Ball Check #4
    • 6 balls later, the logo had completely disappeared. The rough side and shiny side looked like distinct objects at this point. The lacquer had worn off on the rough side.
  • 12:48 PM: Ball Check #5
    • After 18 successive deliveries of sandpapering one side and shining the other – The rough side now had a pinkish-white shade to it. You can clearly see the tear on this side and sandpaper marks.

Final Ball Check #6

  • 1:19 PM: Ball Check #6
    • For this last 12 deliveries, I only shined the ball between deliveries and did not do anything to the rough side

Observation: The pink hue had gone, there were still white marks and scratch patterns on this side. However, the natural wear and tear on this side had increased so if a new bowler looked at this in first glance, they *may not* notice that sandpaper or external substance was being used.

Analysis/Conclusion

I wanted to see how much of a difference we would get between natural proceedings and sandpaper ball tampering.

So, what did I learn from this experiment?

  1. If sandpaper was being sporadically applied (once every couple of overs) or only a couple of swipes at a time, then the bowlers might not have known.
  2. However, if sandpaper was being used between EVERY ball (or almost every) for an ENTIRE session, then there would have been clear, distinguishable marks on the rough side of the ball.

And more than the pattern of the sandpaper marks, it would be the slight discoloration you get if sandpaper is applied enough times on a red cricket ball that would give it away.

The question then becomes:

  1. How often or in what cadence did Cameron Bancroft sandpaper the ball?
  2. How discreet was he being? Was he using sandpaper between every delivery? Or between boundaries and runs so the bowlers/umpires would not notice?

Limitations & Bias

  1. Only Having One Ball: Even though I tried to use the shiny side of the ball as the control variable, it would have been good to buy a couple of other balls and bowl 60 balls without sandpaper for a proper control group.
  2. Only One Player: I did not use this during a live match. There were no keepers (who could catch the ball after the ball exits the pitch to mimic real conditions) or fielders
  3. Ball Type: Although the ball I had was a 156-gram red cricket leather ball, it is not the ICC Kookaburra Turf leather ball that would have been used at Newlands.
  4. Speed: I do not possess the pace or actions of the Australian pace attack. In addition, all my deliveries were bowled right handed, which does not replicate the left arm of Mitchell Starc.
  5. Conditions: A fall day in the USA does not have the same environmental conditions as the 24th March in Cape Town. Still, the weather was great outside today. Temperature was about 60-66 F, which wouldn’t have been too far off from South Africa in March.

Future Directions

If I were to repeat this experiment in the future, I would have made the following changes:

  • Get a few people together who have not seen the experiment and have them observe the ball at different stages to see if they can tell the sandpaper balls against natural condition balls
  • Using a non-carpeted pitch and playing an actual match for 40 overs before we start sandpapering the ball

Final Thoughts

This was a fun little side project I was curious about. Thank you all for reading and watching the videos in the twitter thread.

Now I am left with a

  • Table with a huge sandpaper mark
  • Handkerchief which will never be used again
  • Trouser with small cricket ball marks

And a whole bunch of sandpaper.

****

You may like

Bangladesh lose experienced batter for second Proteas Test

icc-cricket.com13 hours ago

What Sandpapergate reveals about Australian cricket

Al Jazeera11 hours ago

Will Jacks ruled out of reminder of Australia T20I series due to broken hand

cricblog.net6 hours ago

The Ashes tickets and VIP hospitality for England vs Australia cricket Test matches in 2027 from

The Sun3 days ago