BackAs the controversial Sandpapergate scandal is ruling the headlines, former Indian spinner Ravichandran Ashwin has now shared his views on why David Warner may not have spoken openly about the ball-tampering incident earlier. He felt the fear of losing his career behind the scenes.
The Sandpapergate scandal has returned after former Australian batter Usman Khawaja made explosive claims in his autobiography, Sabr. Khawaja stated that the entire Australian team knew about the use of sandpaper on the ball during the 2018 Cape Town Test against South Africa. He also claimed that Australia did the same practice in the previous Test match in Port Elizabeth.
Speaking about the controversy on Jio Hotstar, Ravichandran Ashwin recalled how badly the incident affected Steve Smith. He said Smith was at the peak of his career when the scandal broke and described the scenes of him facing the media after returning from South Africa as painful to watch.
The former Indian all-rounder also pointed out that Cricket Australia had opened a hotline in 2019, asking players to share any information they had about the incident. However, no players came forward through that process. He felt the silence showed how difficult it was for players to speak against the system.
During the discussion, former Indian all-rounder Irfan Pathan questioned why Warner was supporting Khawaja's claims now when he did not speak up or make the same comments when the incident actually happened back in 2018.
Pathan also points out that Warner and Khawaja are very good friends, so it is understandable that the former opener would support him now. But Pathan feels that there are three players on one side and the entire team on the other side, so it is natural for those three players to defend each other.
Ashwin gave a straightforward explanation for the silence, saying, “Their career is at risk. As simple as that.”
Legendary Australia batter Matthew Hayden agreed with Ashwin and said fear could have stopped David Warner from speaking openly. He explained that players may have been worried about the impact their statements could have on their careers.
He also suggested that the latest claims had created anger and debate because people expected someone like Khawaja to speak up if he knew about the use of sandpaper at the time.
Matthew Hayden said during the same discussion: “It's as simple as that. It's fear. I mean, we've all felt it, right? We've felt fear. We feel fear every day of our lives. You know, there's a fear that needs to always have a gentle undertone of acceptance to it. And this is why I think it's caused great rage and debate in Australia. The Usman that I know would have said, Bangers, please, are you kidding? Put the sandpaper away.”
R Ashwin shares his perspective on why David Warner may not have spoken out earlier on Sandpapergate, highlighting the fear of putting one's career at risk. 🏏 Catch Sandpapergate: The Unsettled Debate streaming on JioHotstar! Coming soon 👉 #BorderGavaskarTrophy | #INDvAUS starts 21st JAN 2027!
— Star Sports (@StarSportsIndia) November 17, 2026
Meanwhile, Ravichandran Ashwin has questioned Pat Cummins for strongly rejecting Usman Khawaja's claims instead of addressing the ball-tampering incident. Cummins did not agree with Khawaja's version. He called the claims "100% wrong" and "complete and utter nonsense."
The Australian captain also denied that he or the bowlers knew about the sandpaper being taken onto the field. Reacting to the comments, Ashwin said he was surprised by Cummins' reaction. He explained that Khawaja's main point was about collective responsibility and that the former opener wanted the truth to be discussed beyond the three players who were punished.
Ashwin also made it clear that he respects Cummins as a cricketer but did not expect him to dismiss Khawaja's claims so strongly. He pointed out that Cummins and former captain Tim Paine had worked hard to rebuild Australia's image after the 2018 scandal.
The former off-spinner also appreciated the Cricket Australia CEO's decision not to reopen the investigation but said the controversy exposed the differences in the dressing room.
Ashwin said, “That is a chalk and cheese statement, where he has actually gone on to say contrasting opinions to what Khawaja has given. And David Warner has continued on his own thread of saying what he believes is right. This is concerning, whether we perceive this or how we end up. And I love what the CEO of Cricket Australia has done.
He's come out and said, "We're not going to reopen the case," which I think is the right way to do it. But one thing is very crystal clear in this, Anand, which is that there were cracks in the Australian dressing room in the past in terms of views and opinions on this. And I don't think it is crackless even now. And that would be the more concerning part for me.”
Different perspectives on Sandpapergate! 🗣️ R Ashwin discusses Usman Khawaja's views on team accountability and Pat Cummins' response to the claims surrounding the controversy. 🏏 Catch Sandpapergate: The Unsettled Debate streaming on JioHotstar! Coming soon 👉 #BorderGavaskarTrophy | #INDvAUS starts 21st JAN 2027!
— Star Sports (@StarSportsIndia) November 17, 2026