BackSandpapergate has been so divisive that it has reopened an old feud between the Broad family and Darren Lehmann, with Chris Broad questioning whether the Australian should be coach of Northamptonshire.
In 2013 Lehmann called Stuart Broad, son of Chris, “a blatant cheat” and encouraged Australia fans to get stuck into him. Broad jnr had edged Ashton Agar to slip off the gloves of wicketkeeper Brad Haddin in the opening Ashes Test of 2013, which England went on to win.
Lehmann was implicated by the testimony of Cameron Bancroft on Wednesday, leading Broad snr to question his suitability to coach in county cricket. Broad snr had already attacked Lehmann over the issue last week, and returned for another jab on Thursday.
“The truth has to come out,” Broad snr – who played 25 Tests for England before becoming an ICC match referee – told the BBC. “Is this the sort of coach we want in county cricket? Do we want someone like Darren Lehmann, who could potentially do something similar if Northamptonshire are in a promotion or relegation situation? It is a very difficult one for the ECB and Northants to answer, but questions need to be asked about that.”
Lehmann has coached Northants for two seasons, including to the Vitality Blast title this summer, and there is no suggestion that his role is under any pressure following the revelations.
Lehmann is scheduled to return to the commentary box with ABC for the opening T20 in Melbourne on Saturday, and will have to address Bancroft’s version of events after saying in Hobart that he would take some time to digest them.
At a press conference before the first T20 against England, the Victorian debutant Sam Harper was asked if he could be the feel-good tale Australian cricket so desperately needs.
It will take a little more than a popular local lad with lots of friends and family at the MCG to shift the conversation, you sense. Amid the sandpaper civil war, the atmosphere here has become so febrile and toxic that even this unheralded Australian team trouncing an also under-strength England 5-0 would barely register in the news cycle.
That it was Harper speaking at all told a tale. Before him, England captain Harry Brook had addressed the media, as is standard. But Mitch Marsh, the Australian captain, is said to be in no personal state to tackle questions on sandpapergate.
The likeable West Australian was subjected to a car crash presser before the first ODI in Perth, where he refused to engage with questions about what he knew. Having lost the series in Hobart and been name-checked in his friend Bancroft’s epic sandpaper exposé, he did not speak, and now the word is he may be seen but not heard from throughout this series. He had dead-batted questions in the Melbourne airport arrivals hall on Thursday, but is at least expected to play, the old man in a very green side.
The key figures in the scandal cannot escape it. Pat Cummins, the current captain, was door-stepped at home in Sydney’s beachside eastern suburbs amid calls from Mitchell Johnson and others for him to resign. Steve Smith, who is maintaining a dignified silence, trained at the Sydney Cricket Ground having returned to the country from his customary hideout in Manhattan, but camera crews and journalists were not allowed in to watch him, which is unusual.
England, meanwhile, have clarified that they have no plans to use David Saker, the bowling coach who is implicated in Bancroft’s account, any time soon. Saker was England’s bowling coach under Andy Flower, Australia’s bowling coach in South Africa in 2018, and has been a regular consultant coach under Brendon McCullum, including as recently as last month in Pakistan. But with Tim Southee in place as white-ball bowling coach, Eric Simons in the Test setup, and Troy Cooley running the entire pace-bowling programme, Saker will not be involved again. England say this is not a direct consequence of Bancroft’s testimony, but something that was already decided.
The matter is being discussed by politicians, with Richard Marles, Australia’s deputy prime minister, throwing his support behind “great captain” Pat Cummins, but Andrew Hastie, who is tipped as a future leader of the Liberal Party, is “most sympathetic” towards Bancroft. Hastie was previously in the Australian SAS, and compared the issue with his own experience speaking out after members of his regiment were accused of war crimes in Afghanistan. “Having lived something similar myself through the military, I’m conscious that the truth always comes out,” he said. Elsewhere, Sandpapergate is earning comparisons with Watergate and the JFK assassination.
This is an issue being discussed at every level of Australian society, and Cummins has the most to lose, although he appears to retain the support of Cricket Australia, who may even publicly back him this weekend.
Unicef, for whom Cummins is an unpaid ambassador, has pulled an ad campaign involving him. “We temporarily paused the older campaign advertisement after comments shifted away from the campaign and towards recent reporting about Australian cricket,” a Unicef spokesman told The Sydney Morning Herald. Cummins is arguably the most marketable man in Australia and has deals with Gillette, New Balance and others.
Opinion polls on the sports pages of news websites have swung against him, and the idea – put forward in his 68-minute press conference a week ago – that he can never talk about the matter again is fanciful. His manager Neil Maxwell has issued three statements to the press. In the third, he said “there is currently a hysteria unfounded in reality”.
“I believe Bancroft’s account,” wrote Johnson in The West Australian. “It comes across as real and I could feel the words as he was saying them. He came across as himself and he has nothing to lose now. It also lines up with the most detailed accounts we’ve heard from other players.
“The pressure on Cummins is now immense. I think he will still try to stand by what he has said and his statement with all of the bowlers back in 2021.
“But I think the public pressure for Cummins to stand down as Test captain now will be too much. I just can’t see how his captaincy and personal brand survives this.”
Cricket Australia appears hopeful it will all blow over, and are finalising the terms of reference of their “safe space” forum, a move that is unlikely to tie up any loose ends.
Heavy rain in Melbourne on Friday afternoon, following Harper’s press conference, summed up the mood in Australian cricket. England are missing a raft of key players for a series with a B-list cast, international in name only, but are the top-ranked T20 side, having won 23 of their last 26 completed matches. Harry Brook’s team have an opportunity to add to that, and pile on the pain.