BackSince Shukri Conrad took over as head coach of the Proteas, he has orchestrated one of the most remarkable turnarounds in modern cricket. Under his guidance, South Africa have shed the tag of nearly men to become World Test Champions and the number one ranked side in the world.
They boast enviable depth in almost every department, settled leadership under Temba Bavuma, and crystal-clear roles for their players. Yet, amid all this dominance, one glaring area remains unsettled: the crucial number three batting position.
Since Conrad took charge, South Africa have auditioned a revolving door of batters at first drop. While the coach has rightfully pushed back against the idea that his selections are erratic, the sheer turnover at number three in the Test team tells its own story. Finding someone to bridge the gap between the new ball and the middle order has proven to be the hardest puzzle for Conrad to solve.
Looking back at the players tried at first drop during the Conrad era reveals a pattern of fleeting promise rather than sustained excellence:
Tony de Zorzi was given the early nod when Conrad first took the reins, showing plenty of grit, though his best Test returns have ultimately come as an opener or at number four.
Raynard van Tonder was handed the role during the controversial, second-string tour of New Zealand in 2024, a baptism of fire that yielded few runs.
Tristan Stubbs was tipped as the long-term answer for a period, even striking a memorable 94 against India in Guwahati, yet his natural flair often feels better suited to dictating terms lower down the order.
Ryan Rickelton delivered genuine success at first drop, stepping in against Sri Lanka in Gqeberha in 2024 to score a gritty maiden Test century before occupying the spot against Pakistan in Centurion. However, his subsequent explosion as an opener, highlighted by his monumental 259 at Newlands, and his current role anchoring the lower middle order at six have pulled him away from the position. The middle-order role fits well alongside keeper duties, and he appears to have made six his own.
Wiaan Mulder was deployed as a tactical curveball at first drop in the World Test Championship final at Lord’s and famously smashed a record-breaking 367 not out against Zimbabwe, though his primary value remains as a balance-providing all-rounder.
David Bedingham was the most recent experiment during the just finished 2-1 home series triumph over Australia, where his string of unconverted starts and vulnerability to the short ball ultimately cost him his place.
With Bedingham omitted for the current series against Bangladesh, Conrad turned to a familiar face in Zubayr Hamza. Playing his first Test since February 2024, Hamza walked out at the Wanderers with South Africa under pressure after losing Aiden Markram in the second over while chasing Bangladesh’s imposing 400.
Hamza responded with brilliantly, riding out a tricky early period with a blend of excellent technique and composure, he grew is confidence and stature. Alongside centurion Marques Ackerman, he weathered the early storm before lunch and anchored a massive double-century partnership. His crisp 83 off 129 balls was not just a timely personal milestone; it was the exact blueprint of what a Test number three should do. He absorbed pressure, rotated the strike effortlessly, and allowed his partner to flourish.
So, is Hamza finally the answer? On evidence of both his temperament and his domestic pedigree, he appears comfortably the best option to make the spot his own. Unlike several others tried in the role, Hamza is not a makeshift opener or a middle-order stroke-maker forced up the order. He has spent the bulk of his first-class career batting at number three, boasting a stellar domestic average of nearly 48 with twelve centuries in that exact position.
Alternative arguments, such as shifting Aiden Markram down to first drop to accommodate Tony de Zorzi at the top, only create unnecessary disruption to an opening partnership that is already firing. With a massive home series against England looming in December and another World Test Championship final on the horizon, the Proteas need stability. Zubayr Hamza has earned the right to an extended run, and if he builds on his Wanderers lifeline, Shukri Conrad might finally have the last piece of his world-beating puzzle.