BackTitle winning coach Duncan Parnis said he is 'confused' and 'upset' after being banned for five years
A ‘fantastic’ children’s hockey coach told of his ‘devastation’ at being forced out of the sport he loves after parents complained he shouted too much.
England Hockey has now banned Duncan Parnis, who has previously been honoured as a coach of the year, for five years. It was described as a 'permanent exclusion’ by England Hockey for affiliated activities involving persons under the age of 18.
Among the claims against him are that he failed to shake a child’s hand and left others crying in the dug out. But many at Knole Park Hockey Club in Sevenoaks, Kent, where he has been coaching seven to 18 year olds for six years have leapt to the under-fire coach’s defence. They claim he has brought ‘joy’ to the game and in return has been treated ‘grotesquely’ with little understanding of his autism.
Hockey coach Duncan Parnis says he is appealing a five year ban from Hockey England
Complainants - 22 of them - accused him of ‘belittling’ the children’s performance, shouting at them from the sideline, being derogatory to players, giving negative feedback and making players go into the dugout crying after being criticised. Seven witnesses gave evidence at his hearing, including two children.
Duncan was suspended last June and in January was banned by England Hockey after a hearing of their Child Protection and Welfare Disciplinary panel. The panel deemed the coach caused a ‘potential risk of harm to the safety and or welfare of a young person in hockey.’
But club members claim the 100 emails of support, totalling 30,000 words appear to have been ignored by the panel. Duncan’s supporters praised the coach saying his talent had helped them win 22 national titles in six years.
A hockey coach banned for five years said he was left 'physically shaking' after being suspended last June
Duncan told how he is currently planning to appeal the decision and is taking legal action. The 41 year old, who has coached around 10,000 people over the years, including at least ten Olympians, said: “I'm devastated. It's emotionally been impossible to deal with. But my well-being is of no interest to England Hockey.
He claimed: “This is just a very small handful of disgruntled parents either with me or with my selection decisions. It’s nothing to do with the kids.
“I think the autism is a massive factor too. I think this is a character assassination, fundamentally. My brain wasn't telling me to do things a different way to fit in. I don't enjoy small talk.” He explained how he does not like shaking anyone’s hand.
“The club has every regulation possible in place to make sure that every kid is always 100% safe,” he pointed out, as every coaching session is with another coach he works alongside. All the coaches that have coached with me have all supported me.”
“I have a very open door policy for any other teacher, coach, parent, anyone can come and watch. We've actually invited England Hockey to come and watch our sessions in the past, which they have actually done.”
He told of his “frustration and sadness” that he has been forced to stop coaching. But stressed: “No one ever wants anyone to be upset. I'm sad that it's happened and I'm sad that I haven't been given a fair opportunity to defend myself. There were probably 100 emails that all supported me and I think they named 22 emails that didn't support me, and a number of them were dug up from the past, some left two years ago. “
He said he didn’t give evidence at this hearing because of the ‘lack of transparency’ about how they pick the panel he was judged by.
“I’d say two thirds to three quarters of those who complained because they weren't picked for something. I think the picture that they wanted to paint was we're talking 20, 30 years ago, when a teacher shouts at you in your face. And that was normal back then. Well, that just never happened, ever. “
Talking about the impact it has had on him, he said: “Hockey was everything in my life. I was hockey 24-7. I was probably doing between 60 and 70 hours a week coaching 200-250 people a week with upwards of four to six hockey matches a weekend. Now I’m left twiddling my thumbs.
“I've been doing that you know for 20 years. There's been 22 complaints out of 10,000 people I’ve coached. It's been very difficult, mental health-wise.
“If they come and watch me once a month, once a fortnight in a random hockey match, they're not going to see the relationship I have with their son or daughter that I see four or five times a week, where three, four, five other sessions have been super positive. It's not in my interest to have favorites or to bully someone,” he said.
And about claims he had a bad attitude to referees, he said: “I'm not going to sit here and say I am an angel but I have not been sin binned for two years or something like that, which is quite remarkable. I am a vocal hockey coach, I talk to players, I shout across the pitch, I may be appealing for a decision. “
Backing the coach, Michael Brown, 46, whose two daughters have been members of Knole Park HC for three years, told us: “I have attended almost all of their training sessions and matches. He is a fantastic coach.
“Duncan is very focused on detail and just wants children to fulfil their potential. I would say there is an approach to coaching, where communication rests too much on telling all players that they are brilliant but then sometimes in order for children to improve you need to point out areas they can work on. Unfortunately some parents haven’t liked that despite it being a very necessary part of improvement.”
Michael, a former professional county cricketer and former Chairman of Burnley Cricket Club, is no stranger to different coaching styles after many years in professional sport.
“It is important to combine both praise and constructive comments as part of any player’s development whether young or old. It builds knowledge, skills and most importantly resilience.”
He said: “Duncan is a wonderful hockey coach who has been instrumental in my eldest daughter's development as both a hockey player and person. My daughters both love their hockey and have made so many new friends whilst also becoming so much more confident in themselves, and stronger, more resilient people.”
He described England Hockey’s decision as “unfair and unjustified” and claimed that if parents had known or or been aware of Duncan’s autism, they may perhaps have been more sympathetic to his way of communicating.
"The vast majority of parents understood this and helped their children learn how to react to this in a positive and respectful way which will help them throughout life."
Mum Aynur Ates, a solicitor whose two children were coached by Duncan, said: “I am saddened to see how England Hockey has treated Duncan. What they've done feels not just unfair, but cruel, discriminatory, and deeply abusive.
“England Hockey actively reached out to former members, soliciting complaints. Duncan is one of the most extraordinary coaches I've ever seen. He makes hockey feel joyful, alive. The results speak for themselves: rapid progress, confident play, genuine love for the game.
“To watch England Hockey tear that away leaves me angry, heartbroken, and profoundly sad. The children deserve better. Duncan deserves better.”
Duncan stressed: “I am not saying I am a perfect hockey coach. I'm not a perfect person either. But I've never, ever wanted to upset anyone or not give my best to any player I've ever coached I’ve just tried to give them an environment where they're demanding of themselves. And try and make it as enjoyable as possible.”
England Hockey said: "The process is still on-going, and we won’t be commenting on this while it’s live."