BackMohammed Siraj's omission from India's playing XI for the opening Test against New Zealand at the Basin Reserve in Wellington has sparked debate, particularly after the visitors opted for a four-man pace attack. Despite his experience and recent contributions in overseas conditions, the fast bowler was left out as India backed Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna.
The decision surprised several former cricketers and fans, with questions raised over what Siraj had done to lose his place. India batting coach Sitanshu Kotak has now defended the selection, insisting that the team management picked what it considered the best possible combination for the conditions and the demands of the match.
India's decision to leave Mohammed Siraj out was one of the biggest talking points after Shubman Gill won the toss and elected to field. The team went in with four specialist seamers, but chose Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj alongside Bumrah and Prasidh Krishna. Washington Sundar was selected as the spin-bowling all-rounder, while Ravindra Jadeja also missed out.
Speaking at the post-day press conference, Kotak made it clear that Mohammed Siraj's omission was not a reflection of any particular problem with the pacer's performance. He said the management had focused on finding the strongest overall XI.
"I think at a time they pick the team, they think about best XI, and that’s what played. Nothing wrong with Siraj, they thought best possible XI and played. Sri Lanka were different conditions. Not wrong decision to drop Siraj," Kotak said, as quoted by Sahil Malhotra.
Sitanshu Kotak also explained the thinking behind the pace combination, pointing to the different skills available in the attack.
"Two bowlers swing the ball well and two seam the ball well. And have pace. When you pick XI, you think about all days."
Former India fast bowler Dodda Ganesh was not convinced by the selection call. He questioned why Siraj had been left out despite India choosing four frontline pacers for the Wellington conditions.
Ganesh took to X to express his displeasure, describing the decision as unfair and difficult to understand.
"What has Siraj done to be dropped? Totally unfair this. Unable to come to terms with this," he posted.
What has Siraj done to be dropped? Totally unfair this. Unable to come to terms with this #NZVIND
— Dodda Ganesh | ದೊಡ್ಡ ಗಣೇಶ್ (@doddaganesha) November 19, 2026
Former India opener Wasim Jaffer also questioned the management's decision, particularly because the Basin Reserve conditions appeared suited to Mohammed Siraj's bowling. He could understand Washington Sundar's selection ahead of Jadeja, but felt leaving out the Hyderabad pacer was difficult to justify.
"I can still understand the case for Washington Sundar over Jadeja, given New Zealand’s left handers. But Siraj being left out is absolutely shocking.
"The man who single handedly levelled the England series and is India’s leading wicket-taker in this WTC cycle doesn’t find a place, even in favourable conditions? India are already missing him on Day 1. This is Siraj territory, building partnerships, tiring batters and making things happen with his relentless work ethic. Very difficult to digest! #NZvIND #Siraj," Jaffer wrote on X.
I can still understand the case for Washington Sundar over Jadeja, given New Zealand’s left handers. But Siraj being left out is absolutely shocking. The man who single handedly levelled the England series and is India’s leading wicket-taker in this WTC cycle doesn’t find a place, even in favourable conditions? India are already missing him on Day 1. This is Siraj territory, building partnerships, tiring batters and making things happen with his relentless work ethic. Very difficult to digest! #NZvIND #Siraj
— Wasim Jaffer (@WasimJaffer14) November 19, 2026