BackMatthew Breetzke’s start in Test cricket stands in stark contrast to how he has dominated in One-Day Internationals and is partly explained by a lack of clarity about his approach in the five-day format.
Breetzke has passed 50 in half of his ODI innings, turning two of those into hundreds. But in the Test arena, in seven innings, his highest score is 43. That came in the second innings of the Cape Town Test against Australia and is his best effort, not just in terms of runs scored, but management of an innings.
Breetzke and Marques Ackerman are the newest additions to a Proteas batting line-up that is being given room to fail, because the larger goal of stability is so important.
Ackerman’s 157 in the nine-wicket win against Bangladesh last week at the Wanderers was a crucial step in achieving that goal. That Kagiso Rabada, who took a five-wicket haul and scored a career-best 72, called Ackerman’s knock his highlight of the first Test, demonstrates South Africa’s desperation for the batting unit to click.
“I think the guys who have come in have been incredibly impressive,” said Aiden Markram, who is standing in for the injured Temba Bavuma for the second Test against Bangladesh starting on Monday.
“It was a tough series against Australia and the guys were putting their hands up. Some switched roles, played match-winning knocks and sort of inspired even some of the more experienced players.”
Breetzke’s 43 against Australia, which lasted almost three hours, indicated that he could cope with the demands of Test cricket, even if he didn’t make the investment pay off with a bigger score on that occasion.
“I think the frustration is there, and that is fair,” Markram said of his younger teammate.
“What he’s done in ODI cricket, I think he was hoping to bring that into the Test format and sometimes you just get off to slow starts. It can happen. I think for him now, it’s just about clearing up the approach in terms of how he wants to go about things.
“I think in white ball cricket, he’s incredibly clear with that plan and it’s just about having played a few Tests, which way does he want to go? Does he want to be a guy that takes the game on, or is he happy to accumulate runs over quite a long period of time?
“I just think he was potentially stuck somewhere in the middle in the first few games and the nice thing is it’s taught him lessons and given him the opportunity to come with a nice, clear plan moving forward.”
Markram finds himself in a strange place with his batting too. In Bavuma’s absence he is the most experienced batter in the side that will start on Monday, but his own form has been patchy.
He looked good, especially in the first innings of the Newlands Test where he made 78, but aside from a second innings 75 in the first Test against Australia, an innings that lasted over six hours as he attempted to save that match, he’s not contributed in the manner his talent and seniority in this side warrant.
In fact since that magnificent 136 in the World Test Championship final, the only times he’s made 50 were the two half-centuries against Australia. There have also been seven scores of 20 or more on other occasions, showing he’s made starts and not converted, an annoying habit, batters are always desperate to avoid.
“I’m feeling all right, feeling semi-decent, but I’m just quite hungry to convert starts,” Markram said.
“Especially opening the batting in Test cricket specifically, if you get the opportunity to get in on the day, I think you need to cash in because there can be a couple of tricky ones along the way. So I’m slightly frustrated from that point of view, but it creates that hunger to try and make things right and contribute big for the side.”
As expected the Proteas made two changes to the starting XI that won the first Test by nine wickets, with Tony de Zorzi replacing Bavuma and Anrich Nortje taking the place of Dane Paterson.
SuperSport Park has been the Proteas’ best venue in South Africa, with 24 victories in 30 Tests, and only three losses.