BackIan Healy believes Cameron Bancroft’s account of the Sandpapergate has damaged Pat Cummins’ authority as Test captain, and that Cummins would need to answer it directly if he is to lead with conviction.
Bancroft’s piece in The West Australian on Wednesday said the “whole team”, not just himself, Steve Smith and David Warner, knew sandpaper was being used on the ball in South Africa in 2018. That directly contradicted what Cummins said at last Friday’s press conference, where he insisted he and the bowling group knew nothing. He took that position while rejecting the claims in Usman Khawaja’s autobiography Sabr.
While Cummins hasn't spoken since Bancroft's version was made public yesterday, his agent Neil Maxwell said the Australian captain's position hadn't changed. “I would feel without refuting Cameron Bancroft’s words again, he [Cummins] will struggle to captain the team,” Healy told SEN. “You’ve had a big part of your credibility taken away with that press conference now that it’s been proven to be not as complete as Pat made it out to be.”
The former wicketkeeper didn't call for Cummins to step down as captain as some in Australian cricket circle have, though he did not rule out that Cummins might choose to.
“No, he doesn’t need to stand down,” Healy said. “And I don’t want to get into another panic mode of what happened in 2018, it was panic, and they tried to do an investigation in no time, didn’t talk to anyone, it was rubbish. It was a lack of quality and rubbish, and rushed, and panicked. Now, I can’t say whether he should stand down now. Will he stand down? That might be a different thing. He might stand down.”
Healy was critical of the original inquiry, but added that he didn't think a new investigation was needed either. “No. I don’t think there’s any value in it. The dots are joining for us now,” he said.
“So I’m saying no. It would be costly, it would be ugly, and continuing something that should have been better handled first time, but it could be wrapped up quite well without spending a whole lot of money, I reckon.”
Meanwhile, Chadd Sayers, the 12th man in Cape Town, had come out with his version of the events a few days prior to Bancroft. He had also contradicted Cummins' side of the story. Speaking again to SEN on Sunday he said Bancroft’s revelations had made him regret not going public sooner.
“Knowing what happened is not great and knowing a lot of people were telling the truth and some weren’t,” Sayers said. “But I was pretty comfortable that it had moved on. But now knowing what Cameron Bancroft actually had gone through and all the different scenarios that had happened, I probably wish I did come out a bit earlier.
“It obviously took a lot of courage for Cameron Bancroft to come out and tell his story,” he said. “It has obviously been sitting with him for eight years and taking most of the brunt for what occurred.
“The mental side of things, that he’s been able to just hold himself together and be able to perform at a high level in a high-performance environment - to carry that with you for eight years, regardless of what’s happening right now, is just a credit to him.”
Sayers said he was not yet convinced he will take part in the independent forum CA has set up to hear accounts of 2018. CA chief executive Todd Greenberg said on Wednesday he could not promise that everything from the forum would be made public, and that was part of Sayers’ hesitation. “What’s the point ... if there’s certain bits that they want to cut out,” Sayers said. “I am uncertain on what I am going to do with it. I have spoken ... in a public forum so there’s not much more I have to say on the issue.”
Bancroft, by contrast, intends to take part. Speaking briefly to Nine on Thursday morning, a day after his article was published, he said the release had lifted a long-held weight.
“Well look, obviously yesterday was a really big day for me,” he said. “Really emotional day and obviously [I’ve] been carrying a lot of this stuff for a long period of time, so I feel really freed and really happy to be able to do that.
“And obviously now there’s a process in place which Cricket Australia and Todd [Greenberg] have put, and yeah, I look forward to being a part of that process.”