BackLast Updated on 8 seconds ago by Charbel Coorey
Pat Cummins is in the spotlight once again following Cameron Bancroft’s revelations on sandpapergate. Five days after the Test captain spent over an hour talking to media emphatically denying any knowledge of ball tampering, Bancroft gave a detailed account of the events of 2018 and expressed his disappointment over Cummins’ comments.
“The final straw for me to write this account was Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins’ press conference,” Bancroft wrote in his 4,000-plus-word article for the West Australian.
“It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone.”
Usman Khawaja and David Warner have been vocal in their stance that everyone knew about the use of sandpaper during the South Africa series. Chadd Sayers also shared details. However, Bancroft’s account is particularly damning for the current pace attack, especially captain Cummins in the wake of his media conference last Friday.
“During that period, I regularly spoke to the bowlers about how the ball was behaving. I had to,” Bancroft wrote.
“I recall conversations with all the fast bowlers Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether it was reverse swinging enough.
“I also spoke with Tim Paine, who was in a key position behind the stumps to observe how the ball was moving. I wanted and needed feedback.
“How else am I to know if what I’m doing is effective or not if I don’t have these conversations with the bowlers bowling with it and the wicketkeeper?
“… All the bowlers gave me feedback if my work on the ball was working. It was helpful.
“Is it going yet? It’s not going yet, it needs more. So I would use the sandpaper more on the ball.”
Predictably, reactions are widespread on social media. Some believe that Pat Cummins’ position as Test captain is untenable, while others point to a key Bancroft quote in his article:
“I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used.”
However, Bancroft also wrote, “The conversations about the effect the sandpaper was having on the ball were regular, very natural and organic on the field. It is as it is,” leading to further debates and speculation.
Pat Cummins’ manager Neil Maxwell has responded to Bancroft’s claim. “Whilst we feel for Cam and everything he’s been through, there’s nothing in the statement that hasn’t been answered by Pat in his press conference,” Maxwell said, as quoted by CODE Sports.
Here are some of the reactions to the civil war that continues to engulf Australian cricket.
Daily Mail’s Oliver Holt was quite scathing, writing that Cummins’ credibility is collapsing and that “he cannot remain as captain.”
“Cummins is in trouble. Two more players involved in the South Africa tour, Bancroft and Chadd Sayers, Australia’s 12th man at the Port Elizabeth Test in 2018, have come forward to say that Cummins’ version of events is false,” Holt wrote.
“That is pretty much half the team now who say that everyone knew. And we are still supposed to believe that the bowlers, who would be the most likely to know, were actually the only ones not to know? I’m sorry but that is stretching credibility beyond breaking point.”
Other fans and pundits feel Cummins has no wriggle room. Here are some of viewpoints.
❌ "He's got to be sacked. I'm sorry, this guy is Pinocchio Pat."
— talkSPORT Cricket (@Cricket_TS) November 18, 2026
🤔 "Three of the team say they all knew, are we really supposed to believe that the rest of them are now going to pretend they didn't?"
Piers Morgan reacts to Cameron Bancroft's statement about Sandpaper Gate 🏏 pic.twitter.com/5gcPZ9J4Ep
In light of Bancroft’s statement. Have we now reached the point where the lying and denial of Cummins, Starc et al post sandpaper has now become a bigger crime than the crime itself?
— TheCricketMen (@thecricketmen) November 18, 2026
It’s quite instructive how many people didn’t watch Pat Cummins’ whole press conference because so many keep claiming that all he said was ‘onto the field’ & used ‘lawyer speak.’
— Mark Gottlieb (@MarkGottlieb) November 18, 2026
Yeah… then he unequivocally denied knowing anything about any tampering 👇 pic.twitter.com/hFdv5Cfc9U
Usman,warner sayers and now bancroft have all came out and said everyone knew about it. For me starc, hazewlood and Cummins reputation is ruined Cummins has to step down,doing so would admit guilt. Bit smith took the full blame for this, he should be made Captain #AUSvENG
— coach Lucas (@lukeR15sky) November 18, 2026
Tim Paine and Pat Cummins both got the captaincy on the basis that they had nothing to do with the sandpaper scandal
— Billy Crawford (@BillyCrawford05) November 18, 2026
Turns out they were both in on it from the start
Steve Smith took responsibility and lost his job and these two stayed quiet and profited off it
Aged like milk. pic.twitter.com/2RnPXLH3lR
— Manya (@CSKian716) November 18, 2026
To be honest, I don’t have a problem with the ball tampering issue. At best, the whole team deserved a one-match ban or maybe penalty runs awarded to the opposition.
— Sameer Allana (@HitmanCricket) November 18, 2026
But instead Cricket Australia showed that ohh we took the high road and threw three people under the bus and… pic.twitter.com/LiHejUawLS
Position untenable now. A support staff member will pipe up shortly and he’ll be sacked.
— Craig D (@swansational) November 18, 2026
Pat Goings…
— George Dobell (@GeorgeDobell1) November 18, 2026
I find it so hard to believe that Cummins went out there and lied through his teeth for 70 minutes on live TV.
— Neal Gardner (@Nealbackup) November 18, 2026
But if he did… it might be a wrap. pic.twitter.com/xRGlTXEAhz
Reckon we need to stop talking about people telling their "truths". The evidence is stacking up that we've been told THE truth now by several people whose stories all match up. Not sure how Pat Cummins survives this
— Chris Stocks (@StocksC_cricket) November 18, 2026
Pat Cummins needs to resign. If your whole imagine is based on being squeaky clean, but your integrity is now a massive media question mark, your position is untenable.
— James Morgan (@downatfineleg) November 18, 2026
Other fans and pundits pointed to Bancroft’s comments about distinctions between knowing a ball is reversing and knowing specifically that sandpaper was brought out on the field.
This is a key part of Bancroft’s statement. I deleted some other tweets that I got wrong on this.
— Sandy Lanceley (@sandylanceley) November 18, 2026
Bancroft is seemingly saying that he talked to the bowlers about his work as the ball manager, but he’s not claiming he told them he was using sandpaper https://t.co/FSWOavwwW7
Read the whole thing and I think these details matter. Warner's suggestion, Saker and Lehmann's encouragement. Cam saying not everyone was around. I still think they knew something (or even exactly what) was being done but they didn't know the sandpaper was on the field. pic.twitter.com/7DkNVPqBsc
— M 🏏 (@auscricketfan33) November 18, 2026
Pat is going to keep saying, he didn’t know the paper was taken onto the ground. Discussed, yes, but not taken out.
— Brian Wightman (@BrianWightman76) November 18, 2026
Should those who have always claimed they didn’t know, continue to maintain they didn’t know, how will any of us ever really know that everyone knew?! The conjecture still exists despite 4 men emphatically saying otherwise. 🤷🏼♀️
— ktrimpie (@ktrimpie) November 18, 2026
It remains to be seen what comes out of this ugly episode. Cricket Australia (CA) announced an “independent forum” on Wednesday for players to share their accounts of sandpapergate. However, with so much out in the public, it is hard to see how it could be of any real value.