BackOn the eve of the opening Test in Wellington, India’s bowling coach Morne Morkel was non-committal about Mohammed Siraj being an automatic pick in the playing XI, instead acknowledging the depth of India’s attack. As it turned out, India opted for a four-man pace attack, but Siraj was not one of them when the lineups were revealed after the toss of the opening Test on Thursday (November 19).
The decision seemed vindicated after New Zealand were reduced to 70/5. But once the Basin Reserve wicket flattened out, India’s attack outside Jasprit Bumrah lacked the incision to make inroads as Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips wrested the initiative New Zealand’s way by Stumps.
On the face of it, India may have missed Siraj’s experience, but batting coach Sitanshu Kotak backed the selection call, which saw Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj make the cut alongside Prasidh Krishna. He also downplayed Siraj’s returns on the tour of Sri Lanka having a bearing on his selection for the ongoing Test. Siraj picked up four wickets from those two outings in Sri Lanka in August but more tellingly, his speeds were well below his usual mark.
“There is nothing wrong [with Siraj]. I mean I can't see anything wrong,” Kotak told reporters after the opening day’s play in Wellington. “That's the best possible XI the team management thought and that is the one which played [this game]. Sri Lanka, obviously it was different conditions, and Siraj played both the Tests there.”
When asked if India got the call wrong in hindsight, Kotak begged to differ, even as he later reiterated that Siraj was a “world-class bowler”. He threw his weight behind the selection call, highlighting the variety of the attack India put out on the park.
“Two seam the ball well, two swing the ball well. And obviously pace is one thing because when you are playing on a wicket which is a little damp, soft to start with, with a lot of grass, obviously one with height, which gives [extra] bounce [is an advantage],” Kotak said.
“And this is just the first day - there will be some dents [as the game goes on]. So when you pick an XI, you think about all four or five days.”
Siraj’s omission wasn’t the only call that raised eyebrows. India preferred Washington Sundar over Ravindra Jadeja as the spin-bowling all-rounder, and Kotak reasoned out a left-heavy New Zealand line-up as the factor behind that decision.
“Because there are four left-handers, an offspinner was picked. Not only the first innings, there’s the second innings too. So keeping all that in mind, the decision was made…And he [Washington] can also bat well. Jaddu is obviously an unbelievable all-rounder, he has done so well. But at the time if you feel for this match this is a better combination [you go with it, so] we went with this combination,” he said.
After India had New Zealand on the mat, Phillips’ enterprising strokeplay and Nicholls’ patient approach bailed them out of choppy waters on a surface laden with grass 15 millimeters thick. There was little help with the older ball for the Indian attack to work with, resulting in a 173-run unbroken stand for the sixth wicket.
Kotak acknowledged that there was more help with the new ball, but was surprised that the surface flattened out as quickly as it did.
“It was a sunny day, the weather was good, so it dried out quicker than even the curator would have thought.” Kotak said. “But nobody can control that. If it was a cloudy or cold day, then it could have been different. That is how they prepare wickets in New Zealand. All in all I think it’s been a good wicket. If we would have gone through [for a] couple more wickets, then…we could have got them out quickly.”
Kotak praised the recovery act staged by Nicholls and Phillips, but reiterated a factor that Shubman Gill brought up at the press conference two days out of the Test.
“After 30-35 overs when the ball gets old, the seam of the Kookaburra ball flattens,” Kotak said.
Kotak also acknowledged the lack of experience at the non-Bumrah end and felt that the pacers could have brought the stumps into play a lot more against Phillips, who dominated the off-side region.
“Bumrah, [it’s] just, not only with his line length, the amount of movement he gets, and the way the ball talks, that skill he has,” Kotak said as he lauded the team’s bowling spearhead.
“We can learn from the way Bumrah bowls and he adjusts the things and the skill he possesses. When you have a senior bowler like that, it's definitely a lot of learning for other bowlers as well,” he added.
With the second new ball two overs old, India will hope for Bumrah and his colleagues to reprise their impressive showing in the morning session to try and keep New Zealand’s total under 300.